01/16/1886 - Brooklyn, NY - Remet's Hotel
Collar & Elbow: Fred Beadle (2-0) Charlie Allen
01/26/1886 - Hoboken, NJ - Old Fellow's Hall (200)
Collar & Elbow: MacMahon vs Homer Lane
Boxing: Pete McCoy vs Alf. Powers (cancelled)
Boxing: Pete McCoy (4R) Paddy Crowley [wrestler, subbing for Alf. Powers]
03/31/1886 - New York, NY - Germania Assembly Rooms
Graeco-Roman: Ernest Roeber drew Sorakichi Matsuda
04/06/1886 - Brooklyn, NY - Music Hall
Martin Dempsey def John Mott (2/3)
George S. Michling (Young Bibby) (2-0) L. Landerwassa
Amateur Mixed Styles: Mike Haas (3-0) Charles Hines
04/10/1886 - Brooklyn, NY - Music Hall
Collar & Elbow (2/3): Martin Dempsey def Young Sheridan
04/24/1886 - Brooklyn, NY - Music Hall
Collar & Elbow: Martin Dempsey (1-1) Sheridan
06/16/1886 - Paterson, NJ
Graeco-Roman: Ernest Roeber vs Prof. Hoeffler
08/13/1886 - Brooklyn, NY - Alexander Hunter's Road House
Catch-as-catch-can: Charles Cullum (2-0; for $25) John Schummerman
09/11/1886 - Brooklyn, NY - Athletic Association
Graeco-Roman: Cattanact def George Ross
Researches by Hisaharu Tanabe, with additional information from Jimmy Wheeler