Last updated on 06/01/2016

11/29/1853 - Brooklyn, NY - Cumberland St. & Park Ave.
Square Back Falls: Molineux (Aaron Hewlett) (3-0) Caesar Coit
* Either two hips and one shoulder or two shoulders and one hip to be on the carpet simultaneously, to constitute a fall.

01/17/1854 - Brooklyn, NY - Three Mile House (2,000+)
Square Side-Hold: Caesar Coit (3-1) John Mingo

02/27/1854 - E. Brooklyn, NY - George Over's Half Way House
Caesar Coit vs John Nelson (cancelled)

06/05/1854 - Brooklyn, NY
Jas E. Smith (2-1) George H. Leese

10/06/1856 Jas. Buckley - New York, NY - William Butler's Chelsea Manor House
Lancashire Style (2/3 falls): Jno. Robinson vs Thos. Ashton

01/02/1857 - New York, NY - William Butler's Chelsea Manor House
Pete Donoho vs J. Barnes
* Was primarily a boxing show.

09/??/1857 - New York, NY
* Sometime between 09/08 and 09/18 (inclusive).
Thomas Ashton def Robinson

09/22/1857 James Farrish - Brooklyn, NY - Adelphia Rooms
Lancashire / Catch-as-Catch-Can: Peter Lord (forfeit) Thomas Ashton

01/29/1858 - New York, NY - Chinese Assembly Rooms (211; $118.16)
Louis Ainsworth (1-0) John Farley

04/12/1858 - New York, NY - Armory Hall (attn: "by no means large")
Collar & Elbow: Lyman E. Fuller (2-1) Henry Hills

??/??/1858 (sometime after 10/20) Elias Ireland - New Paltz, NY - Ireland Corners (206)
Side-Hold/Square-Hold-Flop/Back-Hold: Dr. Frazier (2-1) Abram Herrington

12/18/1858 - E. Newark, NJ
Lancaster / Catch-as-Catch-Can: Edward Sharp (2-1) "a young man" (of E. Newark)

 

Researches by Hisaharu Tanabe, Jimmy Wheeler