02/05/1863 - Jersey City, NJ - Hudson House
Collar & Elbow (15min per round): Lt. Ainesworth def F.D. Bunnell (2-1)

08/17/1864 - New York, NY - Cremorne Garden
Collar & Elbow: John Farley drew Joseph(?) Lawler
Uzile Prickett def Harry Hill

05/31/1869 - New York, NY - Harry Hill's
Homer Lane def Harry Grace (2-0)

06/27/1870 - New York, NY - Hunter's Point
Collar & Elbow Match: Tim Delacor def George Spiers (3/5)

06/03/1873 - Brooklyn, NY - Gothic Hall
John McMahan def Homer Lane

08/07/1873 - New York, NY - Harry Hill's
Cornwall & Devon Style: John McMahan drew Albert Ellis

08/17/1873 - New Haven, CT
Middleweight Title: William L. Kennedy def Homer Lane

10/23/1873 - New York, NY - Harry Hill's
John McMahan def Albert Ellis

12/18/1873 - New York, NY
Homer Lane def W. Richardson

01/29/1874 - New York, NY - Harry Hill's
Devonshire Style Match: Darby Doyle def William Ashley (1hr 40min)

03/07/1874 - New York, NY - Wood's Gymnasium
Homer Lane drew Matt Grace (1-1)

11/17/1874 - Trenton, NJ - Hibernia
New Jersey Lightweight(?) Title*: James Batley def David Howard

02/13/1875 - New York, NY - Wood's Gymnasium
Ryan def Cole

07/20/1875 - New York, NY - McGinn's Saloon
Collar & Elbow Match: Pat Finnigan def Jim Nolan

10/16/1875 - New York, NY - Grand Opera House
Prof. William Miller vs. Andre Christol

11/24/1875 - New York, NY - Gilmore's Garden
Greco-Roman Handicap Match: Andre Christol def Thiebaud Bauer (30:00 ftt)

11/26/1875 - New York, NY - Gilmore's Garden
Andre Christol def Jaques du Mortier

11/27/1875 - New York, NY - Gilmore's Garden
Andre Christol def Matt Grace

12/11/1875 - New York, NY - Grand Opera House
Thiebaud Bauer def Andre Christol (2-1)

12/25/1875 - Brooklyn, NY - Chermont Avenue Rink
Prof. William Miller def Louis Carteron (3-2)

12/28/1875 - Brooklyn, NY - Olympic Theater
Louis Carteron Fay vs. Professor Gary Miller

12/29/1875 - New York, NY - Grand Opera House
Greco-Roman: Andre Christol def Thiebaud Bauer (3-2)

05/12/1876 - Brooklyn, NY - Howe's & Cushing's Circus
Prof. William Miller vs. Johnny Dwyer

05/13/1876 - Brooklyn, NY - Howe's & Cushing's Circus
Prof. William Miller vs. Johnny Dwyer

05/15/1876 - Brooklyn, NY - Howe's & Cushing's Circus
Prof. William Miller vs. Johnny Dwyer

05/16/1876 - Williamsburg, NY - Howe's & Cushing's Circus
Prof. William Miller vs. Johnny Dwyer

05/17/1876 - Williamsburg, NY - Howe's & Cushing's Circus
Prof. William Miller vs. Johnny Dwyer

05/18/1876 - Greenpoint, NY - Howe's & Cushing's Circus
Prof. William Miller vs. Johnny Dwyer

06/05/1876 - Brooklyn, NY - The Rink
Albert Ellis def Harry Howard
Boxing: Billy Edwards drew Steve Taylor

08/09/1876 - Brooklyn, NY - Central Garden
Johnny Dwyer def Joe Coburn

08/30/1876 - New York, NY - Central Park Garden
Sparring Match: Johnny Dwyer vs. Joe Coburn (11 rounds)

03/20/1877 - New York, NY - Metropolitan Riding Academy
Prof. Thiebaud Bauer def Prof. William Miller

05/12/1879 - New York, NY - Gilmore's Garden (3,000)
Catch-as-catch-can (w/ jackets): John McMahan def William Miller (2-1)

05/14/1879 - New York, NY - Gilmore's Garden (renamed Madison Square Garden 16 days later)
William Muldoon def Thiebaud Bauer

08/06/1879 - New York, NY - St. James Opera House (450)
American Collar-and-Elbow Heavyweight Title*: John McMahon def James Owens

10/04/1879 - New York, NY - Madison Square Garden [original; formerly Gilmore's Garden] (1,500)
John McMahan drew William Miller (2-2 curfew)

10/22/1879 - New York, NY - Madison Square Garden [original]
Edwin Bibby def Andre Cristol (dec)